Pros:
1. Encourages responsible behavior: The FCC’s fine for not deorbiting the satellite sends a message that companies operating in space must take responsibility for their space junk.
2. Promotes a cleaner cosmos: By enforcing fines, the FCC pushes satellite companies to actively work towards reducing space debris and keeping the space environment clean.
3. Sets a precedent: The fine establishes a precedent for holding space companies accountable for their actions, fostering a culture of responsible space operations.
4. Protects other satellites: Clearing out defunct satellites reduces the risk of collisions, which can damage or destroy active satellites critical for communication, weather monitoring, and more.
5. Spawns innovation: The need to avoid fines and comply with the regulations can drive satellite operators to develop new technologies and strategies for satellite disposal.
Cons:
1. Financial burden: Dish Network’s $150,000 fine, as well as the costs associated with implementing a compliance plan, may pose a significant financial burden for the company.
2. Potential disputes: There might be disputes over the severity or fairness of fines, leading to prolonged legal battles and uncertainty regarding enforcement.
3. Limited deterrence: The effectiveness of fines as a deterrent depends on the financial capabilities and risk tolerance of individual companies. Some may see the fines as a mere cost of doing business.
4. Regulatory challenges: Implementing effective compliance plans and monitoring adherence can be challenging for both the FCC and satellite companies.
5. Innovation slowdown: Strict regulations and potential fines may discourage smaller companies from entering the space industry or limit their ability to experiment and innovate.
context: https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/3/23901428/dish-network-fined-space-junk
Dish Network hit with $150,000 fine by FCC over EchoStar-7 satellite issue. Compliance plan to be enforced.
