Should AI companies be required to inform the federal government about their most powerful models?

Pros:
– Increased transparency: Requiring AI companies to inform the federal government about their most powerful models can enhance transparency and provide insight into the capabilities and potential impact of AI systems.
– Risk mitigation: With information about these powerful AI models, the government can assess potential risks and take necessary preventive measures to ensure the safety and well-being of the public.
– Accountability: By reporting their most powerful models, AI companies can be held accountable for the potential consequences of their technology, fostering a sense of responsibility and ethical development.

Cons:
– Trade secrets and competitiveness: Requiring disclosure of the most powerful AI models may compromise a company’s trade secrets, hindering their competitive advantage and potentially discouraging innovation.
– Lack of specific criteria: Determining what constitutes a “most powerful” AI model can be subjective and challenging. Without clear guidelines, companies may face ambiguity and uncertainty about what they should report.
– Regulatory burden: The requirement to inform the government about their powerful models may impose additional administrative burden on AI companies, diverting their resources and hindering their ability to focus on research and development.

Note: The lists provided are based on the general considerations surrounding the subject and do not take into account specific circumstances or details of President Biden’s executive order.

context: https://www.vice.com/en/article/y3wxxj/ai-companies-building-most-powerful-models-must-inform-feds-biden-executive-order-states

President Biden has issued a comprehensive executive order on AI with a two-fold objective: reducing potential risks to the public and providing support to companies operating in this domain.